Skip to Content

7 Best Mafia Reverse Harem Books

Check out my list of recommended best mafia reverse harem books below! I’ve read all of them, and many are some of my all time favourites.

Forget-Me-Not Bombshell by Caroline Peckham, Susanne Valenti

mafia reverse harem books
Series: Mafia Wars #5
Genre: Reverse Harem, Romance, Dark Romance, Contemporary, Crime, New Adult

I was sold to my enemies.

The Butchers of the London mob who run an empire built on sin and greed. The stories I’ve heard about the way they rule their underworld are enough to make my heart race. But those rumours have nothing on the truth.

Danny, Church, Frank. The three men who own me now. The head of this so-called kingdom and the two savages who enforce his wrath.

They made a peace deal with my family which came at a cost – me. A mafia princess gifted to them as a bride.

So here I am in my white dress with a gun to my head and a knife in my garter.

I won’t become their plaything. I won’t become their prize.

The war between our families might have ended with this union, but I’m starting a battle of my own. And I’ll trade my body for a chance to leave this wedded bliss behind.

The only question left is whether they’ll be the ones bleeding out, or if I’ll end up with my heart torn from my chest and fed to these hungry British dogs.

I don’t think it’ll be an exaggeration to describe it as one of the most popular mafia reverse harem books out there, and rightfully so.

This dark romance series is made-up of standalone mafia reverse harem books and are all super good. Highly recommend!

Red Handed by Kate King and Jessa Wilder

Series: Mafia Wars #5
Genre: Reverse Harem, Romance Contemporary, Dark Romance, Adult, Crime, MM

“I need her. Name your price.”

At twenty-three, you would think I could say no to being traded to the enemy, but that’s not how life works when you grow up in an organized crime family. I consider myself lucky to have grown up at all.

Ten years ago, my brother was murdered in the gang war that split the city of St. Adrian down the middle. My family took the South Side, and the North Side went to them. The Gentlemen.

Now the leader of the Gentlemen is asking for my help and my father has been nice enough to agree to his terms. In exchange for my sister’s protection, I need to cross the divide and live with the family that killed my brother.

Too bad I’ve never been great at playing nice.

Nico, Beck and Rush are the enemy. The leaders of the Gentlemen. They’re conceited, lying, murderous assholes and they’re the reason I’ve been trained all my life to cheat, steal, and shoot my way to the top.

I’m ready to take them down from the inside. I just hope they don’t get to me first. After all, a truce between two enemies is a promise waiting to be broken.

Are you sick of high-schoolers running mafias in mafia reverse harem books?

Well I have a recommendation for you where the characters are in their mid-twenties.

Forget-Me-Not Bombshell by Caroline Peckham and Susanne Valenti

Series: The Harlequin Crew #1
Genre: Reverse Harem, Romance, Dark Romance, Contemporary, New Adult, Crime, Adult, Suspense

Dead girls don’t feel pain.

But they like the taste of vengeance.

Maybe that’s why I came back to my hometown. Because it sure as hell wasn’t for the surf. But what else was I supposed to do when I found myself in Sunset Cove with twenty bucks to my name, the key to my enemies’ secrets hanging around my neck and a mouth full of grave dirt that wouldn’t wash clean?

I hate the Harlequin boys.

But this is the perfect opportunity to take what they owe me. Because once upon a time, they broke my heart, stole my life and sent me away from everything I’d ever known.

Fox, JJ, Chase and Maverick.

The four names tattooed onto my heart more permanently than any of the ink on my skin. They don’t just live in this town anymore, they rule it. And the view here may be beautiful, but the sun, sea and sand hide dark secrets.

The gangs.
The lies.
The violence.

It all lurks beneath a veil so thin that once you’ve seen through it, you can never close your eyes to the truth again.

But I don’t plan on closing my eyes. I have four devils set in my sights. And this dead girl no longer has anything to lose.

Caroline Peckham and Susanne Valenti are very popular reverse harem authors and their series always have great enemies to lovers, this series included.

Recommend if you have read and liked their previous books, especially mafia reverse harem books.

Hate by Tate James

Series: Madison Kate #1
Genre: Reverse Harem, Romance, Dark, Contemporary, New Adult, College, Mystery

“Madison Kate Danvers was murdered tonight.”

Those words changed my life, and not for the better.

They were wrong, of course. I wasn’t dead. But I was set up.

After being charged with a string of offences–and made an example of by my political minded father–I’m eventually released back into Shadow Grove with one thing on my mind.

Hate.

Someone is going to pay for derailing my carefully laid out future. Someone is going to catch the full force of my hate. How very convenient that someone just moved into the bedroom down the hall from me.

Archer D’Ath and his boys messed with the wrong chick and they’re about to learn just how cold Madison Kate’s hate can run.

This is one of the mafia reverse harem books with a very badass and strong heroine that does not put up with anyone.

Making the series very satisfying to read. It is also one of the most popular mafia reverse harem books out there.

7th Circle by Tate James

Series: The Harlequin Crew #1
Genre: Reverse Harem, Romance, Dark Romance, Contemporary, New Adult, Crime, Adult, Suspense

Dead girls don’t feel pain.

But they like the taste of vengeance.

Maybe that’s why I came back to my hometown. Because it sure as hell wasn’t for the surf. But what else was I supposed to do when I found myself in Sunset Cove with twenty bucks to my name, the key to my enemies’ secrets hanging around my neck and a mouth full of grave dirt that wouldn’t wash clean?

I hate the Harlequin boys.

But this is the perfect opportunity to take what they owe me. Because once upon a time, they broke my heart, stole my life and sent me away from everything I’d ever known.

Fox, JJ, Chase and Maverick.

The four names tattooed onto my heart more permanently than any of the ink on my skin. They don’t just live in this town anymore, they rule it. And the view here may be beautiful, but the sun, sea and sand hide dark secrets.

The gangs.
The lies.
The violence.

It all lurks beneath a veil so thin that once you’ve seen through it, you can never close your eyes to the truth again.

But I don’t plan on closing my eyes. I have four devils set in my sights. And this dead girl no longer has anything to lose.

Saint Ruby by Vincent

Series: Saint and Sinners #1
Genre: Reverse Harem, Dark Romance, Contemporary, New Adult, Romance, Crime, Adult, Mystery, Erotica

It’s a common story. I’m sure you can guess how it goes.

The girl winds up in the wrong place at the wrong time.
She witnesses four gods of beauty and brutality murder some poor sap, and she’s stupid enough to get caught.

Come on. You know what happens next.

You know they tracked her… me… down.
I don’t need to tell you that they claimed me. Ripped me from my safe, perfect world and bound me in chains to their throne.
All of that is obvious.

It’s the part where they corrupted me, dragged me into their world of death and destruction, made me theirs in every way I didn’t know was possible, and I became a soldier in a war that will bring all of Cinco City to its knees…

…that’s when it gets interesting.

Carnage by Sarah Bailey

Series: Four Horsemen #1
Genre: Reverse Harem, Dark Romance, Contemporary, BDSM, Erotica, Adult, Crime

Prescott Ellis – Pestilence

They call us The Four Horsemen.
Four friends forged in fire and blood.
No one knows where we came from nor how we got our name.
Drake, Francis, West and I rule the financial industry like kings.
Gods in our own right.

We grew up with a fifth. A girl. Scarlett.
She was one of us until she was ripped away from her life. The only trace of her was dust in the wind.

One day she returned to the city and sought us out. Scarlett couldn’t remember who we’d been to her, but we recalled her all too well.

If she knew what was good for her, she would have never come back. The moment she stepped through the doors of Fortuity, it was the beginning of her end. And the start of our reign over the girl who wanted us dead.

A dark why choose (MFMMM) contemporary retelling of the four horsemen of the apocalypse set in Sarah Bailey’s Dark Universe with cliffhangers and a HEA in the final book.

This is a DARK romance and therefore comes with a content warning. Please see the author’s website for full details.

I really recommend this if you want more reverse harem series like Four Psychos by Kristy Cunning. Hint: it’s because of the Four Horsemen themes.

As many readers may know (especially romance book readers), oftentimes we like to seek out book tropes and read romance books that include the book tropes we usually like and the book tropes we want to read at the moment. It’s what drives a lot of book recommendations and is a common way we seek out books to read.

If you are a reader who is interested in:

  • Tracking tropes that you have already read
  • Tracking tropes that you would want to read in the future
  • Collect original trope ideas that you came up with (and haven’t come across before)

Then this book trope reading journal is perfectly made for you!

Please subscribe to my mailing list to get a FREE colouring book, and follow me on my social media accounts if you want more posts like this! I really appreciate the support <3.

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.